Please join us on November 30, 2015 from 6-8pm at the Bozeman Library Community Room for this amazing discussion.
Tags: military, military history, suicide, veteran, Veterans Day
By John W. Olsen
You’re not alone.
This coming Wednesday marks the 61st occurrence of Veteran’s Day since it became a Federal Holiday in 1954. For many years men and women have fought for and died for our country and unfortunately a certain portion of them died by their own hand: Suicide.
Suicide has been associated with mental illness and something being wrong with a person and is inaccurate. A great analogy I found on Suicide.org is that if you have a broken limb, you go to the doctor or the Emergency Room and get it taken care of. Why is it not the same for suicide and why is there so much difficulty to talk about? Check out the following link to find out more about the stigma of suicide. http://www.suicide.org/stigma-and-suicide.html This stigma is very slowly being changed and it is still a difficult battle.
When I went online to find out the number of veterans who commit suicide it is hard to find a definitive answer. One thing is certain, though, the difference between military and civilian rates of suicide are staggering. Going to VA.gov and looking at the 2012 Suicide report http://www.va.gov/opa/pressrel/pressrelease.cfm?id=2427 and at the bottom of the page is a link to the full 59 page report. This data, of course, is not complete as there are states that haven’t released information, information released does not acknowledge the event was a suicide, or it does acknowledge the individual was a veteran. This information is broken down into many different categories.
In January of this year the LA Times ran an article about a study that “…included all 1,282,074 veterans who served in active-duty units between 2001 and 2007 and left the military during that period” and “It tracked the veterans after service until the end of the 2009, finding a total of 1,868 suicides. That equates to an annual suicide rate of 29.5 per 100,000 veterans, or roughly 50% higher than the rate among other civilians with similar demographic characteristics” http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-veteran-suicide-20150115-story.html. In June of this year the LA Times ran another article this time focusing on female veterans and found “Female military veterans commit suicide at nearly six times the rate of other women” http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-female-veteran-suicide-20150608-story.html
Trying to find actual information on veteran suicides in a historical context is difficult at best. There are some websites that list that approximately 58,000 veterans died during Vietnam and some say that the suicides resulting from that conflict are anywhere between 9,000 – 100,000.
World War II veteran suicide rates after the war didn’t even seem to be on the radar until more recently. According to a spokeswoman for the VA the idea of mental health, especially PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder), wasn’t something that was discussed or even comprehended back then and you definitely couldn’t have gotten care for this at the VA. It was suggested that many veterans self-medicated with drinking and other outlets. https://www.baycitizen.org/news/veterans/suicide-rates-soar-among-wwii-vets/
Today the VA and other mental health providers understand the extreme pressures members of the armed forces have had to endure and symptoms of which don’t necessarily appear immediately. It is true that we do have more resources and hotlines available for veterans and yet we still have men and women taking their own lives. We still have a ways to go.
Thank you to all the veterans for your service, your patriotism, and your sacrifice. We would not be here without you.
Perhaps the most courageous act a veteran who is considering suicide can do is to ask for help. Below is a list of resources for veterans and civilians.
586-3333 – Help line
John W. Olson
USN 1989 – 1992
Our own Marsha Fulton shares her research on 19th century Spiritualism in this presentation for the 2015 Montana History Conference.
Tags: german concentration camps, germany's reconciliation, Jewish holocaust, racial history, racial profiling
Germany Works towards Reconciliation
Julia Strehlau is a graduate of the Native American Studies department of Montana State University. As a native of Germany, she offers an inside perspective to Germany’s reconciliation with its difficult history.
As a German citizen who has traveled much around the United States I soon experienced that questions about Germany’s Nazi history came up quite frequently. The holocaust is really one of German history’s darkest chapters, and also one that Germany is dealing with until this day. In my experience it is nothing that is being hidden or not talked about, quite the contrary. Within my school career during history and politics classes World War II was talked about extensively. We were made aware of the cruelty of German politics at the time, visited concentration camps that are now historic memorials and had to write lengthy papers about the time. Education is one way to deal with the past. But what about reconciliation? How can a country apologize for murdering six million Jews? This is the question I want to deal with here.
After May 8th, 1945 Germany’s government was completely taken down by the Allies. The United States, Great Britain, France and the Soviet Union took over central decisions and governance until 1949. Germany was then separated into the Federal Republic of Germany and the German Democratic Republic. (As history will tell, in 1961 the two German countries were separated by “the wall”. It came down in 1989 and eventually ended socialism in East Germany. Today the Federal Republic of Germany encompasses the area of both East and West Germany, where the same values are shared.) With the foundation of the Federal Republic of Germany in May 1949 it was provided with a Basic Law that constitutes the values of life among all people in the country. Its first article entails that “the dignity of man is inviolable. To respect and protect it shall be the duty of all public authority”, and article three says: “No person shall be disfavoured because of sex, parentage, race, language, homeland and origin, faith, or religious or political opinions. No person shall be disfavoured because of disability”. Therefore, the government diminished its own powers in being able to discriminate and persecute.
This Basic Law limited the possibility of another Holocaust and also provided those Jews who still lived in the country an opportunity to live a life in freedom and peace. Other than Native Tribes that have received an official apology by the colonial powers, there is no official apology by the German government to the Jewish people. I assume that the reason for that is that the Allies took over the government right after the war, and that in 1949 two completely reorganized countries were founded.
However, Germany’s first chancellor Konrad Adenauer in 1951 said: “In the name of the German people indescribably awful crimes have been committed” and emphasized West-Germany’s willingness to pay for these crimes. The compensation or ‘Wiedergutmachung’ for war terrors was paid in reparations by West-Germany. In 1952 the Luxemburg agreement also called the Reparations Agreement between Israel and West Germany was signed by those two countries with the goal “to find a solution for the materialistic compensation-problem in order to ease the way for emotional cleansing of the infinite distress” (translated by me). West-Germany therefore agreed to help to economically stabilize the state of Israel, which was founded in May 1948, for twelve years, and also paid reparations to Jewish individuals who survived the terrors of World War II. Until the re-unification of Germany in 1989, East-Germany paid reparations to Poland and the Soviet Union.
Reconciliation in form of money and economic support for the injured of course cannot compensate the damage that has been done. Until today, however, Germany pays reparations and distances itself from the injustice of World War II. The reparations serve as a symbol to confess Germany’s guilt in the Holocaust.
Diplomatic relationships between Israel and West-Germany were non-existent until twenty years after the war. The first German ambassador to Israel, Rolf Pauls, arrived in 1965, and the first Israeli ambassador was welcomed in Bonn in the same year. At the time Pauls was welcomed under protests by the Israeli people, but within his term in office sentiments in Germany and Israel towards the other country improved immensely.
Another twenty years later, the German President Richard von Weizäcker delivered a speech on May 8th, 1985, the 40th anniversary of the end of the war in Germany. He called it the Day of Liberation despite the day of capitulation, which it was referred to until that day. He stated that on that day in 1945 Germany was liberated from the inhumane national-socialistic tyranny. He further argued that a collective guilt cannot be applied to the German people though he said that the former generation has left a difficult heritage and called his fellow Germans to accept that heritage. His speech was not only well received and very important to Germany. Translated into twenty languages, Weizsäcker’s speech represented a different Germany, with a different mindset and world view. He was invited by the Israeli government and was the first German President to visit Israel.
Of course I do not want to leave out that many of the high ranking Nazis of the Third Reich left Germany after the war and were never held responsible for their wrong doing. Others filled seats in the succeeding German parliament. Germany undoubtedly made mistakes in the aftermath of World War II. But I do feel like Germany has accepted its difficult heritage. One will find well maintained Jewish cemeteries in Germany. Memorials and synagogues are being built and re-built. Houses, lots, and money are given back to Jews until this day. There is at least one moment of silence every year being held in the German Bundestag and elsewhere in order to commemorate the victims of World War II. I really have to say that many things are being done so that the German people do not forget their ugly historical heritage.